A dilemma from dilemmas.day
You are a juror in an assault trial. You know 100% the defendant is guilty because you overheard a real recording, but the judge threw it out due to a police error. Without it, there is insufficient evidence.
Still open. What would you do?
Your vote is anonymous. Votes on past dilemmas don't count towards your streak.
Current split · aired 2026-08-27
52%48%
Vote guilty508 votesVote not guilty
52% chose “Vote guilty”.
By country
- Spain1 votes
What each choice meant
A · Vote guilty
You voted guilty. You prioritized moral justice over the law.
The Vigilante — You seek substantive justice over procedural technicalities.
B · Vote not guilty
You voted not guilty. You let him go to uphold the legal system.
The Legalist — You defend rules and systemic limits to protect everyone from abuse.