A dilemma from dilemmas.day
You are a juror in an assault trial. You know 100% the defendant is guilty because you overheard a real recording, but the judge threw it out due to a police error. Without it, there is insufficient evidence.
AVote guilty
You convict the offender and protect future victims, but you violate your judicial oath and the law.
BVote not guilty
You respect the law and due process, but a dangerous offender goes free and may strike again.
Sealed 2026-08-27
52%48%
Vote guilty508 votesVote not guilty
52% chose “Vote guilty”.
By country
- Spain1 votes
What each choice meant
A · Vote guilty
You voted guilty. You prioritized moral justice over the law.
The Vigilante — You seek substantive justice over procedural technicalities.
B · Vote not guilty
You voted not guilty. You let him go to uphold the legal system.
The Legalist — You defend rules and systemic limits to protect everyone from abuse.