A dilemma from dilemmas.day
Your child will die if they don't get a kidney transplant in 24 hours. There is a matching organ from a deceased patient with no family, but they signed a document refusing to be a donor. Only you have access to that file.
Still open. What would you do?
Your vote is anonymous. Votes on past dilemmas don't count towards your streak.
Current split · aired 2026-08-18
47%53%
Destroy the file384 votesRespect the signature
53% chose “Respect the signature”.
By country
- Spain1 votes
What each choice meant
A · Destroy the file
You forged the consent. Your child lives.
The Blood Protector — Your family's life comes before any signature or law.
B · Respect the signature
You respected the paper. Your child died waiting.
The Ethical Doctor — You respect the rules and rights of others, no matter your personal pain.